I paddled the Pigeon in 2011 and again in 2019. Both times were in late July to early August. The water was quite a bit lower in 2019 than it was in 2011. I've also paddled the Berens and Bloodvein. The Pigeon is my favorite of the three.
The Pigeon was easier at lower water. More of the rapids were runnable and more importantly from your perspective since you're planning to mostly portage anyhow, the approaches were less intimidating and the run-outs below the rapids had far fewer swirls and boiling eddy lines.
Although the ground tends to be somewhat lower west of Round Lake, we still had plenty of nice campsites. In particular, we had good campsites at rapids 35, 41, 45, and 47 (numbering system from Hap Wilson's "Wilderness Rivers of Manitoba").
Clearcutting was not at all a problem.
In 2011, the road was not there yet, so we got flown out on a float plane near a power line a few miles upstream of Lake Winnipeg. In 2019, we took out at the road (which is just downstream of rapid 51 on Hap's maps).
FYI, we flew in from Bissett with Bluewater Aviation. However, a couple of months after our trip, the plane we chartered crashed into Family Lake and the pilot and 2 passengers were killed.
https://www.tsb.gc.ca/eng/securite-safety/aviation/2019/a19c0138/a19c0138-d1-a1.htmlI'm not sure what the status of Bluewater's operations out of Bissett is now.
Current and very helpful information. Much appreciated. News of the plane crash is shocking - very tragic. Bluewater seems to be still operating though I haven't yet given them a call. Thanks again.